What Can Happen If You Refuse to Sign Divorce Papers
The Short Answer: Refusing to sign divorce papers can result in an unfavorable default judgment, loss of rights, contempt charges, and other negative consequences. Signing protects your interests in the divorce proceedings.
While you may think refusal buys time, one hidden clause in divorce law means stalling this way can cost you big - find out what it is…
Going through a divorce is difficult under even the best of circumstances. The dissolution of marriage is stressful, but refusing to provide your spouse's signature on the divorce paperwork and failing to file a response with the family court can significantly complicate matters and limit your rights in the dissolution of the marriage. This comprehensive article examines the potential consequences of a spouse's refusal to sign divorce documents and provides proactive tips to protect yourself legally and financially. This article is not legal advice and seeking the advice of a skilled attorney to help you navigate your divorce-related issues is recommended.
Consequences of Refusing to Provide Your Spouse’s Signature
If the refusing spouse will not sign the divorce papers when asked, either by dodging service or declining to sign after being served, several unfavorable outcomes may occur for the divorce case:
Default Judgment Could Be Entered Against You
If you refuse to put your signature on the divorce petition, your spouse can still pursue a divorce through default judgment. This means your spouse can request the court to grant the divorce and issue rulings on child custody, child support, spousal support, and division of property based entirely on your spouse’s one-sided petition.
The court will likely approve most or all of what your spouse asked for in the petition since you did not file a response or show up to contest their requests in the divorce proceedings. Your spouse does not need your agreement or participation to get a default divorce judgment entered.
You Forfeit Your Right to Have a Say in Key Divorce Terms
By refusing to sign and file a response to the divorce petition within the legally required timeframe (usually 20-30 days from being served the notice of the divorce), you give up your legal right to have any input on critical aspects of the divorce and could receive a default hearing.
This means you completely lose your ability to influence or weigh in on key issues like child custody arrangements, visitation rights and schedules, child support calculation and amounts, spousal support or alimony amounts and duration, and the division and distribution of marital property and debts.
Since you did not respond as required, the divorce court will rely entirely on the requests made by your spouse in the one-sided divorce petition when making default rulings on these important divorce terms. Your wishes, opinions, and interests will not be considered or represented at all.
The Court Can Find You In Contempt for Ignoring Court Documents
If you intentionally dodge being served the divorce petition and summons, or you simply refuse to sign and return the papers after being properly served, the court has the right to find you in contempt of court. This is because you would be deliberately disregarding and ignoring lawful court process documents.
The possible penalties for being found in contempt can include court fines, community service hours, being ordered to pay your spouse’s legal fees, or even jail time in more extreme cases of defiance. You do not want to make an already difficult situation worse by refusing to participate.
Your Spouse May Get Much More Favorable Judgment Terms
When the court only hears one spouse’s side of the story and does not have any input from the other spouse, it tends to accept most or all of the requests made by the participating spouse. This means your spouse could get very beneficial default judgment terms that favor them greatly, while your rights and interests could be severely compromised.
This is especially true for sensitive issues like child custody, visitation, and support arrangements. But it also applies to property division, where your spouse could get an unfair share of assets and a reduced portion of marital debts. By completely avoiding the legal process, you give your spouse's lawyer free rein to craft proposals that benefit their client while disregarding your rights.
Refusing to Sign Can Significantly Drag Out the Divorce Process
Refusing to put your signature on the divorce petition paperwork and file a response within the legally mandated timeframe does not stop the divorce from happening. What it does is draw out the process substantially by forcing your spouse to have to pursue default judgment motions and hearings that otherwise would not be necessary.
This makes the divorce process take much longer to complete, often many additional months. It also drives up the legal costs with extra attorney fees for motions, court appearances, filings, service of process fees, and more. An uncontested divorce where both spouses sign and file is much faster and less expensive for everyone involved.
A Process Server May Be Sent to Personally Serve You Multiple Times
If you intentionally dodge being served the summons and divorce petition, the court will likely direct the process server to make multiple attempts to locate and personally serve you the documents directly into your hands (personal service).
This may involve the process server tracking you down at home, at work, or anywhere else you frequent until you are successfully served. Ignoring the server and refusing to accept service could mean the documents are simply left in your presence. Refusing service altogether can ultimately result in your spouse pursuing and being granted a default judgment.
Private Investigators Can Be Hired to Track You Down and Serve You
If a standard process server is unable to locate and serve you the divorce papers after multiple diligent attempts, your spouse may hire a private investigator who has added resources and methods to successfully track you down.
Private investigators have access to extensive databases, public records, and other channels that allow them to locate people effectively. Once you are found, they can lawfully serve you the summons and petition. Avoiding service is difficult when up against a seasoned private investigator.
Are you finding this article helpful? You might enjoy these articles: What happens when a spouse dies during divorce? Read about 20 ways to respond to divorce threats. This comprehensive article explains how to deal with a vindictive spouse during divorce. Learn more about the effects of a restraining order during divorce with this article.
Real-Life Case Examples of Consequences from Refusing to Sign
To understand how refusing to sign divorce papers could impact specific situations, here are two detailed examples of actual divorces where a spouse declined to sign and the effects that followed:
Case Study 1 - John’s Refusal to Sign Costs Him His Rights and Assets
John and Jane had been married for 10 years when Jane filed for divorce. When the divorce petition was delivered, John refused to sign the papers because he was still hoping to salvage the marriage somehow.
Jane provided John time to respond as legally required in their state. When John still refused to sign after 30 days, Jane hired a private investigator who was able to successfully locate and personally serve John the documents.
With proof of successful service, Jane’s divorce attorney filed for default judgment. At the final court hearing which John did not attend, the judge approved all of the requests Jane had outlined in her petition:
Jane was granted full physical and legal custody of their two children. John would only have visitation rights every other weekend. This was despite Jane traveling frequently for work.
Jane’s requested child support calculation was approved, based on John’s full income. The amount was at the high end of the child support guidelines.
Jane was awarded a significant amount of spousal support for an extended duration, reducing John’s take-home pay.
Jane was granted their marital home, investment property, and 75% of liquid assets. John lost out on his share of equity and savings.
John was assigned most credit card debts even though Jane primarily did the spending.
Once the default judgment was entered, John had severely limited recourse. His refusal to participate in the legal process cost him dearly in the final outcome. John regretted assuming that refusing to sign would stop the divorce.
Case Study 2 - Mark’s Defiant Refusal to Sign Costs Him His Kids
Mark was absolutely blindsided when his wife Susan had divorce papers delivered to his workplace. While Mark knew they had some marital issues, he never thought Susan would take such drastic action.
In a defiant knee-jerk reaction, Mark childishly tore up the documents on the spot in front of the process server and refused to sign anything. This did not deter Susan one bit. She hired a bulldog divorce attorney who followed through by having a private investigator track down Mark and serve him again.
Despite being presented the papers a second time, Mark continued his obstinance and refused to sign again on principle, even after the private investigator warned him of risks like losing custody of their two young children.
Susan's lawyer filed for an emergency custody hearing which was granted given Mark's behavior. At the hearing which Mark did not attend per his lawyer's disastrous advice, the judge awarded Susan full temporary physical and legal custody of their children plus excessive child support based on exaggerated income claims by Susan.
Mark finally realized the gravity of his mistake and tried to reverse course, but the damage was done. Mark ultimately lost primary custody because he had established a precedent and never recovered from his early missteps.
How to Protect Yourself When Your Spouse Refuses to Sign Divorce Papers
While your first reaction may be to reciprocate by also refusing to sign the divorce petition served to you, this will likely not end well for you. Here are proactive steps to protect your rights if you cannot obtain your spouse's cooperation and signature and your spouse declines to sign:
File a Timely Written Response with the Court
To avoid getting stuck with a default judgment that gives your spouse everything they asked for, it is imperative that you have your written response filed with the court within the legal deadline, usually 20-30 days from when you were served. Your response outlines what settlement proposals from your spouse you agree with and disagree with. It is your chance to tell the court your side and set the record straight on inaccurate claims by your spouse. Hire an attorney immediately if you need assistance filing a thorough and strategic response.
Speak to an Experienced Divorce Attorney About Your Situation
You should consult with a qualified local divorce attorney very early in the process to discuss your rights and best options when your spouse refuses to sign. An attorney experienced in family law legal services from a reputable law firm can guide you regarding your state's laws and procedural rules. They will advise you on your next step with how to respond and represent your best interests going forward in this difficult time. Many divorce attorneys offer a free initial consultation, so take advantage to get expert insights into your unique situation. Hiring an experienced family law attorney is almost always the best thing for you to obtain favorable terms in a divorce hearing. Seeking the help of a lawyer to negotiate the terms of your divorce can be the best idea for various reasons, especially during the stressful process of having an uncooperative spouse.
Attempt Good Faith Negotiation First
If your spouse has refused to sign the divorce petition because they do not agree with certain terms and settlement points, see if a constructive dialogue can be opened to potentially reach mutual compromises. Especially for sensitive issues like child custody arrangements, support amounts, and division of property, give negotiation a chance before digging in your heels. If direct talks break down, suggest mediation as a way to come to an agreement.
Remember That Signing Only Acknowledges Receipt of Documents
It is important to understand that you signing the divorce petition when served only acknowledges that you received the documents. It does not indicate that you agree with or consent to any of the settlement terms, custody arrangements, or other proposals from your spouse at that stage. You still have the full right to dispute aspects of the petition you deem unfair in your specific situation before a final judgment is entered.
Contest Issues and Assert Your Rights Before a Final Judgment
Make sure to formally dispute any unsatisfactory or inaccurate elements of the petition during conferences and hearings with the judge before a final divorce decree judgment is entered. This preserves your ability to protect your rights and ensure your interests are fairly represented in the final written judgment. Any issues not raised at this stage may be difficult to revise later.
Conclusion – Why Refusing to Sign Divorce Papers Is Almost Always a Bad Idea
Refusing to sign the divorce petition served to you by your spouse is contrary to your own interests in nearly every case. Unless upon close examination there are very limited and specific parts of the petition you contest, you should sign to avoid the risks of default judgment, show the court your willingness to participate in good faith, and retain your rights. Work with an experienced divorce lawyer/attorney so you can be strategic and selective in contesting only very unfair or unacceptable proposals. Keep communication open with your spouse early in the process to potentially reach compromises. Refusing to sign limits your voice and control over your own divorce. Protect yourself by responding thoughtfully, asking for help, and asserting your rights.
The good news is you can get divorced without excessive court appearances and legal fees in many cases. If you and your spouse are able to communicate and cooperate enough to reach agreements on the terms of your divorce, it is possible to handle much of the process yourselves and finalize your dissolution of marriage without litigation.
As you navigate the intricate terrain of legal options and considerations involved in the divorce process, it's essential to ensure that every aspect is thoroughly examined. In some cases, seeking professional guidance, such as consulting a knowledgeable private investigator, can shed light on possibilities during a divorce like child custody investigations, infidelity, and alimony. If you require expert insights to navigate this challenging journey, the good news is Salt Lake Investigations stands ready to assist you with a friendly free consultation in uncovering the comprehensive information you need.
